Gustavo Petro’s dream of becoming an inspirational leftist leader who would jettison Colombia’s conservative economic orthodoxy is fading just 10 months into his presidency — stymied by scandals hitting top aides and the defection of allies in his coalition.
Instead of leading a peaceful revolution to lift millions out of poverty, Petro now risks spending the next three years as an unpopular lame duck, wasting much of his energy defending himself in investigations. The prospect of such a gridlock is all but certain to anger voters who hoped he’d usher in a wave of changes. But it has been welcomed by investors, who never trusted the economist and former guerrilla, or liked his reforms.
“We see this stagnation in almost all governments, but normally in their last year, whereas this one is beginning,” said Andres Mejia, a political analyst who teaches at the business school in Bogota’s Andes University. “This wouldn’t be in a problem if we were talking in 2025, but we’re still in 2023.”
Since taking office, Petro repeatedly spooked markets, including by criticizing the central bank and shaking up the leadership at the state-run oil company. Now many of those same investors are turning bullish on the country, betting Petro’s troubles make it less likely he can carry out his agenda. That’s helped fuel a rally in the nation’s bonds and sent the peso surging 15.3% this year, making it the best-performing major currency.
“Some of the biggest concerns on the political front are diminishing, and it’s due to a combination of factors, for example the rupture of the coalition in congress, Petro’s diminishing popularity, and Colombia’s strong legal framework and institutions,” said William Snead, a fixed income strategist at Banco Bilbao Vizcaya Argentaria SA, in response to written questions.
Dollar bonds have outperformed peers over the last month, and funds managed by BlackRock Inc., Schroders Plc. and Barings LLC. have poured money into local currency government bonds.
Even after the recent run-up, Snead said assets remain cheap, meaning there’s room for the rally to continue. Colombia’s shrinking current account deficit, improved fiscal outlook and inflows from corporations to pay taxes are also bolstering the peso. The currency extended gains in early trading on Wednesday, appreciating to as much as 4,181 per dollar in Bogota, its strongest level since last August, the month Petro took office.
Plenty of Risk
From investors’ point of view, there’s still plenty of risk: Petro still has three years in office and his hostility to the oil industry and his management changes at Ecopetrol SA have alarmed some holders of the state driller’s bonds.
Petro’s press office referred a request for comment to the finance and interior ministries. Finance Minister Ricardo Bonilla said by phone that the peso rally can’t be attributed to recent scandals, since it predates them.
Colombia has sent a message of economic stability that provides calm to financial markets, Bonilla said.
Read more: Leaked Audio Deepens Scandal Engulfing Colombian Government
Leftist incumbents in Brazil and Argentina have also suffered falling popularity in recent months amid rapid inflation, while Peru’s unpopular socialist leader, Pedro Castillo, was impeached in December when he tried to dissolve congress.
Crumbling Coalition
In Colombia, Petro’s ruling coalition began to crumble as his ambitious bills to boost worker benefits and overhaul the health and pension systems worked through Congress. The measures sought to slash the role of private companies in delivering medical and investment services, alarming lawmakers in the Conservative, Liberal and U Parties. First they tried to water down the bills, only later to just to pull their support outright.
In recent days, the government has been hit by a widening investigation into allegations of phone tapping, abuse of power and breach of campaign finance rules by some of the president’s closest aides. The revelations are now effectively threatening to put Petro’s agenda on hold as Colombia’s political parties shift their focus to the October elections, when voters will elect mayors and state governors.
Presidential Power
After those elections, Petro, who belongs to the Historic Pact alliance of leftist groups, will have an opportunity to get his agenda back on track if he’s able to rebuild alliances with lawmakers, said Sergio Guzman, the director of Colombia Risk Analysis, a Bogota-based risk consultancy. But that would likely require him to make large concessions to rival parties and a “major cabinet overhaul that actually includes different viewpoints,” — a step he said wouldn’t be the president’s “preferred option.”
Even without a majority in congress, the presidency still wields great power in Colombia, with the ability to name magistrates to the highest courts, central bank co-directors and the military high command. He can also rule for a time by decree, though that would likely be eventually stopped by the courts.
Phone Tapping
Polls showed the president’s approval rating was already in steep decline even before his chief of staff and his former campaign chief were forced out last week in the biggest scandal to hit his government so far.
That one erupted when a woman who had been employed as a nanny by Petro’s chief of staff, Laura Sarabia, told reporters she had been interrogated and improperly subjected to a polygraph near the presidential palace. Sarabia had accused the woman of stealing thousands of dollars in cash.
The woman also had her phone intercepted, according to the Attorney General’s office. Sarabia left the government last week.
It got worse when Semana magazine published a foul-mouthed tirade by Petro’s former campaign manager Armando Benedetti, who Petro fired as ambassador to Venezuela the same day Sarabia left office. Benedetti suggested that the 2022 campaign had violated spending rules, and threatened to dish the dirt on the source of some of the money.
Since there are still so many unanswered questions, the scandals are likely to drag on for a prolonged period, paralyzing the government’s agenda, Guzman said.
“Not that the President will resign, or that he’ll be impeached, or anything like that,” said Mejia, the analyst from Andes University. Rather, it would mean “that his ability to conduct policy and pass reforms is probably dead.”
--With assistance from Ezra Fieser, Davison Santana and Robert Jameson.
(Updates peso move from 4th paragraph.)
